Entwistle's Error Recipe

A Historical Sip

The origin of "Entwistle's Error" is shrouded in delightful mystery, much like its name suggests. Legend has it that this drink was created by a masterful yet whimsical bartender named Entwistle, who, in a happy accident, combined dark rum, lemon juice, and tonic water. While the original recipe may have been a stroke of serendipity, the result is a sophisticated and refreshing cocktail that has stood the test of time.

Why You’ll Love It

There’s something truly harmonious about the combination of dark rum, tangy lemon juice, and effervescent tonic water. It strikes a perfect balance between robust and refreshing, making it an ideal choice for both casual get-togethers and more refined gatherings. The sweet depth of the dark rum mingles seamlessly with the citrusy bright notes of lemon juice, rounded off with the bubbly lift of tonic water. It's versatile, vibrant, and exceptionally easy to make—what’s not to love?

What You'll Need to Make the Recipe

Dark Rum

The heart and soul of "Entwistle's Error" is undoubtedly the dark rum. Known for its strong, molasses-like flavor and rich caramel hues, dark rum acts as the foundation of this cocktail. It provides a robust and slightly sweet depth of character that elevates the entire drinking experience. For those looking to experiment, aged rum can offer more intricate flavors such as vanilla and spice.

Substitution: If dark rum isn't available, spiced rum can be an exciting alternative, adding some extra layers of flavor complexity.

Lemon Juice

Lemon juice is the zesty counterpart that introduces a refreshing acidity to the mix. Its tartness perfectly complements the sweetness of the dark rum, creating a beautifully balanced drink. Freshly squeezed lemon juice is always the best choice as it adds a vibrant, sharp citrus note that is unparalleled.

Substitution: Lime juice can serve as a substitute, though it will bring its own distinct tangy character to the drink.

Tonic Water

The effervescent element of the cocktail, tonic water, contributes a slight bitterness and fizziness that ties everything together. It cuts through the sweetness and adds a refreshing finish. Tonic water with a hint of added flavor, such as elderflower or citrus, can also work beautifully.

Substitution: Club soda can be used in place of tonic water if you’re looking for a milder taste profile.